Local business? Support local news on LittleElm.city

Back to Texas

State Supreme Court turns away cities' challenge, leaving the 'Death Star' limit on local ordinances in place

Houston, San Antonio and El Paso lost their bid Friday to revive a lawsuit against the 2023 law that bars city and county rules going beyond state law. Democrats say they will seek repeal in January.

Tessa Cho· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

November 20, 20262 min read

A 2023 state law that limits how far Texas cities and counties can go in writing their own rules will stay in force after the Texas Supreme Court declined on Friday, Nov. 20, to hear an appeal from three of the state's largest cities.

Houston, San Antonio and El Paso had challenged the law, which critics nicknamed the "Death Star bill," The Texas Tribune reported. By refusing the case, the high court left standing a 3rd Court of Appeals decision that sided with the state.

That appeals court had reversed an August 2023 ruling by a Travis County judge who found the law unconstitutional, concluding the cities had not shown how it harmed them or why the state was responsible. The law took effect while the case was pending.

What the law does

The measure prevents local governments from adopting rules that go further than what broad areas of state law allow. The Tribune pointed to local regulation of payday lending and required water breaks for construction workers as examples, and said some local noise and car-towing ordinances were taken off the books after it passed.

Local officials have said the law is so broad that it is hard to tell which rules are now off limits, and that it has made them wary of trying policies that could bring lawsuits, according to the Tribune.

The two sides

Gov. Greg Abbott, Republican lawmakers and business lobby groups pushed for the law, arguing it protects business owners and economic growth from a patchwork of local rules. Critics have described it as a way for Republican lawmakers to block progressive local policies.

What comes next

Democrats, who now control the Texas House and statewide offices, plan to push for repeal when the Legislature convenes in January 2027. Gov.-elect Gina Hinojosa told the Tribune this week that she wants the law repealed, and state Sen. José Menéndez, a San Antonio Democrat, has filed a repeal bill.

Any repeal would still have to pass the Texas Senate, where Republicans hold the majority and where the Tribune said the idea is likely to meet stiff resistance.

Sources

The Texas Tribune

Share

Tessa Cho· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Tessa Cho writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Little Elm.

Related Stories

More in Sport